Push for State Flag for Karnataka, India

Chief Minister Siddaramaiah of the Indian state of Karnataka is arguing for the region, which lies in the south west of the subcontinent and which was previously known as the State of Mysore, to have its own flag, as well as calling for more autonomy for states.

The Flags of the World website explains that, “State flags are not found in India – only the national flag is flown on state buildings.” I understand that Jammu and Kashir is, hitherto at least, the exception.

This flag is seen in the state, but it is not official:


The New India Express explains,

Dispelling the apprehension that it could strengthen the feelings of separatism, Siddaramaiah has said, ” I don’t think the demands for greater federal autonomy and recognition of regional identity are inconsistent with our nation. Karnataka prides in Kannada identity. The oldest written document (in stone) in Kannada found at Halmidi, Hassan District, dates back to 2nd century AD. The oldest Kannada kingdom under the Kadamabas of Banvasi ruled the state during the 4th century AD. We have been using a red and yellow flag since decades. Yet, Karnataka, as our poet laureate Kuvempu said, is the daughter of Bharata, the Indian nation (Jaya Bharatha Jananiya Tanujathe).”

It is probably a matter of time before other states adopt their own flags.  Karnataka has a population of over 60 million and its capital, Bangalore, or Bengaluru, is India’s fifth largest city with over eight million inhabitants.

In a recent survey, conducted by the global HR consultancy Mercer, Bangalore was voted the most liveable city in India, however life is not so easy at the moment due to a water shortage.

New apartment blocks are being completed in the city, India’s Silicon Valley, but water is being delivered by tankers to provide for those already living in the metropolis.

I suppose it is only natural that people in the world’s second largest country,  by population, full in diversity, would want recognition for their particular culture. A flag is very useful for symbolising this distinctness!

Food Fight Over Flags

Walkers, the famous Scottish biscuit brand, has come under fire from some Scots for using the Union Flag on the packaging of a few of their many products aimed at overseas markets and for sale as British souvenirs.

Objectors claim that it will devalue the efforts made at marketing Scotland to the World and some have vowed to boycott the company’s products for the rest of their sojourn on this earth.

Whether they ever bought Walkers’ products in the first place, we shall never know, but I have found that very few people are competent boycotters.

I boycott many companies, usually over more weighty issues, for example, I have avoided buying anything made by Nestlé for many years due to their infamous campaign to convince African mothers to use their milk formula rather than to breast feed their children. The deaths of many children have been attributed to the company.

In addition, Nestlé cocoa is produced in the Ivory Coast using child and slave labour. They even admit that the supply chain has issues with child labour, but claim that it is a problem which is difficult to monitor.

Really? “The world’s leading Nutrition, Health and Wellness company” cannot properly monitor its supply chain? Clearly not. Even if one percent boycotted the manufacturing giant, would they care?

This post is getting political, but I will return to flags in a moment. I have also been boycotting Tesco’s for about twelve years over several issues, including the horrible way they have acquired many of their town centre supermarkets, ousting local traders using subterfuge.

The story of Linwood, once the home of Scotland’s only major car plant, is one example of the lengths they have gone to in order to destroy their opposition.

Talking of Tesco’s, they have also been involved in a flag war of their own. Supposedly, customers in England objected to the Scottish saltire on punnets of strawberries (if a ghastly plastic container can rightly be termed ‘punnet’).

It is true that Scottish produce is usually marketed as such, while English products are ‘from the UK’ and they don’t get to see the St George flag on their food. I think I saw it on the wrapper of cheddar once, but it is not a common sight.

Since nationalism increased north of the border, there seems to have been a corresponding increase in bitterness on both sides of Hadrian’s Wall.

It is ironic that the Scottish National Party is in love with the European Union to the extent that their fanaticism over what they call “independence” could be more reasonably described as the desire for dependency on Brussels.

If they do achieve their aim – and the pursuit of real independence would not be an ignoble endeavour – it probably won’t be too long before the EU flag is emblazoned all over shortbread packets along with “Made in the EU” on the back.

Would they accept this particular Union flag in place of the Union Flag or, for the matter, the St Andrew’s Cross?

I wonder how many nationalists have an EU flag on the licence plates on their car.

What do you think? Should shortbread be Scottish or British? Does it matter? I love shortbread, so it won’t taste any different, but could the loss of Scottish identity harm our industry more than successive governments have?

Feel free to share your thoughts, below.